Being Conservative in a Liberal Town Can Be an Isolating Experience

A few years ago I was seeing a therapist who told me he could commune with nature and heal people by sitting next to them. He swims in the ocean every morning and once, sensing his transcendental empathy, a whale surfaced near him and they shared a profound moment of bonding. A few weeks later, my girlfriend’s dog bit him.

One topic we talked about constantly was politics. To be clear, he talked politics and I, well, I smiled and waved. 

If you’ve ever seen the animated kids movie “Madagascar,” you know where I borrowed that phrase from. Those penguins are my role models. “Smile and wave” basically means, “go along to get along.” It means nodding even when you disagree and not making waves, with the aim of avoiding uncomfortable conversations. It’s my solution all for potentially awkward social situations. It’s why, when I quit that therapist after a year, he still didn’t know that I was (and still am)…conservative.

Yes, I understand that I may have transformed before your eyes into a monster. That’s why I don’t tell many people. Philosophically, I am homeless here in Newburyport. It’s obvious whenever a new acquaintance brings up politics and automatically assumes we share the same views; it’s obvious when my social media feed is flooded with posts demonizing people like me, who believe what I believe; it was obvious when I’d drive to Plum Island through a gauntlet of Harris/Walz signs. I know it goes both ways, depending on your information ecosystem and where you happen to live, but this has been my experience in our particular blue enclave.

Living among lots of smart people who espouse such polar opposite beliefs often makes me wonder if I’m wrong. Because of this I find an open mind to be imperative. If I reject everything I hear out of hand, then I’m just being ignorant. So I try to listen, and I measure what I hear against what I know. Consequently, I find myself — at least several times a week — smiling and waving, repeating agreeable phrases like, “yeah, totally” and “wow, that’s crazy,” drawing from the many months of practice in my ex-therapist’s office.

I have good friends, and I’m lucky to have them. Frankly, I do not want to know what their politics are. I don’t want to find out that despite their kindness, they could be triggered by the revelation of my political bent. I don’t want to find out that my supportive friends might suddenly reject me. It’s not worth it. I know what I know and I’m content to keep it to myself, though I often feel adrift in a homogeneously blue sea.

Unfortunately, if you find yourself identifying with the subject of this article — particularly in the wake of election season — and are hoping for a definitive solution, there really isn’t one. The easiest thing you can do is train yourself not to care what other people think. That’s hard with politics because no matter which way you swing, when you hear someone from the “other side” speak, all you hear is, “hi, I’m here to burn the world down.”

My only piece of advice is: People need to be allowed to choose to burn the world down, and you need to be ok with it. Focus on the people you care about and who care about you. If you’re good to them and provide a good example, they may end up believing what you believe. Otherwise, kiss your attachment goodbye. Another tip — find someone you can talk to, someone either likeminded or very open-minded, and decompress through conversation with this person as often as you need to. These are valuable friends. Finally, and maybe most importantly, learn how to organically smile and wave.

Peter Neverette
Newburyport resident

Passionate about a local issue? We want to hear from you. Check out our submission guidelines.

Subscribe to our Newsletter


Comments

37 responses to “Being Conservative in a Liberal Town Can Be an Isolating Experience”

  1. Walt Thompson Avatar
    Walt Thompson

    Good insights.

    Curious what the writer feels makes one a “conservative.”

    1. Legitimate question.

    2. Right. It’s a spectrum or at least should be.

  2. I’d imagine this commentary resonates with a lot of like-minded individuals in the area, including across the bridge. As a former member of the Amesbury Republican Committee, we were viewed as subhuman to some people. When posting an invitation to the Amesbury RTC annual dinner on social media, someone responded “in case you wanted to know where the towns misogynists and Nazis meet, now you know…” It was appalling. What was more disheartening was the amount of “likes” his comment got and how no one called him out (people actually defended him). I am inclined to think this is how many view us on this side of the aisle. Unfortunate indeed.

  3. ClipperCityGuy Avatar
    ClipperCityGuy

    This is a really thoughtful piece, much of which I agree with. Thanks for publishing.

    Though as a slightly left of center centrist that is increasingly concerned about what the extremism on both sides means for the (near-term) future of our nation, I do take some pause with “My only piece of advice is: People need to be allowed to choose to burn the world down, and you need to be ok with it. “

  4. Times have changed politically. Many people wear their politics on their sleeves as opposed to generations ago, people didn’t really talk about it except maybe at election time. As far as signage during an election cycle, not particularly unusual. I think you’d find many different yard signs but it could be a case Baader-Meinhof phenomenon. Now seeing signs or flags when there’s no upcoming election, that could be a case of over identification. Interesting that you continued to see a therapist that talked politics instead of the personal issues you were there to address. I hope you find some answers to your conundrum.

  5. Being a psychotherapist should have absolutely nothing to do with the politics of their client. Yet, as a new psychotherapist in Newburyport, I know from personal life experience and going through the process of achieving a Masters in Applied Psychology from NYU, it does.

    New graduates are told to go forth as “social justice warriors” and IF they come across a client with a more “conservative” bent, it is “incumbent upon them to change their client’s mind”! THIS is wrong on SO many levels! This is NOT the job of anyone, let alone someone in a mental health profession.

    We are supposed to be helpers, and this is one major reason I will have nothing to do with the APA, ACA, or their list of “ethics” because what they deem as “ethical”, I deem more unethical.

    I have clients from both sides, and do not impose my views on anyone or let my own personal views affect helping my clients.

    We are each unique and individual and as such, should be able to have our own thoughts, opinions, and the right to own those without being shouted down or turned away from. I have definite, personal thoughts and feelings because I am a human being. Yet, I would never desire to make someone’s therapy, and helping them navigate through life’s various issues, about their politics. That said, if a client were to ask me for a thought or opinion on something they’re grappling with, and that issue is political in nature; then it’s up to me as their therapist, to determine how much personal disclosure I care to give in my response, and not make them feel like they’re wrong for their beliefs. My job is to suppprt, not to coerce; and coercion should never be a part of any therapist’s job.

    1. I was going to comment about a therapist talking about their personal experiences. I am completely shocked at this “New graduates are told to go forth as “social justice warriors” and IF they come across a client with a more “conservative” bent, it is “incumbent upon them to change their client’s mind”!”

      That is just wrong.

    2. Samson Racioppi Avatar
      Samson Racioppi

      This is not one of those cases where someone in the comment section mockingly asks for a link or references to your discuss (generally in bad faith).

      I truly, genuinely would love to see any lists of “ethics” that these medical orgs are promoting. Many medical decisions in the past five or so years by policymakers have, in my opinion (for what THAT’S worth), engaged in egregious violations of ethical rules, domestic laws (state and federal), and perhaps international laws as well.

      Thanks in advance

  6. This is so much deeper than conservatives vs. liberals. I’d be a lot more sympathetic if conservatives weren’t always trying to take things away from people, instead of giving. Taking away human rights, free meals for kids, bodily autonomy, LGBTQ+ rights, etc is reprehensible in my opinion. Voting for a felon and rapist who lies constantly is also morally wrong. If you have a hard time admitting to friends that you are conservative, maybe it’s because you feel some shame in being one.

    1. And you are an example why i won’t put up a yard sign, or tell people what side ( if any) I lean.
      Both sides deem it acceptable to demean and name call all the others that could be so wrong.

    2. Michele J Avatar

      Just had to resort to the name calling. It gets old . You know NOTHING about me and MY conservative views

      1. Where is the name calling? Must have missed it.

    3. You’re exactly who he’s talking about!

    4. Rose B Clincy Avatar
      Rose B Clincy

      Agreed !!

    5. Jessica
      Just want you to know you have my support for your post and that I agree with you completely !

      1. Sata nawal Avatar
        Sata nawal

        Oh isn’t that nice. Two mean girls!

    6. Patricia Grimes Avatar
      Patricia Grimes

      You are absolutely correct Jessica. Since when did being conservative mean you get to take my rights away? That’s the problem. I do not care if you are Republican or Democrat. I DO care when you start voting in people that want to systematically undo all of the progress in women’s rights, LGBTQ rights, the planets’ rights, civil rights. Hey, think what you want, but stop trying to play God. Stop your judging and hating and trying to make me like you.

      1. Patricia.. exactly. Do I ask someone what political party they belong to before I offer assistance to someone, or donate items to them? Absolutely not. That being said, I’m very tired of the horrible comments and lies told about people who are immigrants, undocumented workers, people who are transgender, etc. The right is vilifying groups of people to distract from the fact they really cannot control the price of groceries and gas.

        1. It you can lie about conservatives. Got it.

    7. Julie Bainbridge Avatar
      Julie Bainbridge

      Well said ! Thank you !

    8. Ray Bannister Avatar
      Ray Bannister

      “Undo your rights”, like the right to keep and bear arms without infringement? How do you feel about that?

    9. Leann dunn Avatar
      Leann dunn

      This is the whole point of the article. Get some self awareness. And maybe some different talking points.

    10. Samson Racioppi Avatar
      Samson Racioppi

      How’s the weather way up there on that high horse of yours?

      Conservatives:

      One of the best reasons to disclose that you are conservative to other people is that the most divisive and hateful individuals — those who we do not wish to associate with — end up outing themselves for everyone else to see.

  7. Virginia Bates Avatar
    Virginia Bates

    A fellow alumna once asked me, “How can you be so nice and still be a Republican?”.

    Expressing views of fiscal conservatism,individual rights, pursuit but not a guarantee of financial success and happiness, and limited government intrusion and giveaways is a way of changing the wrong (and ugly) impression expressed above.

    1. Thank you.

    2. Virginia,
      As many others have stated, it’s not conservatism or even conservative vs liberal as the basis for political debate. The Republican political view is needed as are the Democratic views of opposition. Historically speaking, these varied orientations have provided the balance which has enabled our democracy to survive. That Republicanism and the conservative view have evolved to those of one Donald Trump negate that balance. In turn, these views have created a political atmosphere of us vs them with that same conflict being reflected in multiple social concerns as well. Masks, vaccines, international conflict, and basic human decency now seem to be based on political alignment. Conservatives need to come to the realization that it’s not their right to express political and social position that comes into question, but rather their allegiance to a leader of highly questionable moral character. Evidence of that immorality is readily available on line.

      1. Well said.

  8. I find myself engaging with both sides of the isle at the state house because, well, they are people. To the individual who followed up with: ‘people need to be allowed to choose to burn the world down,’. Ahh, no. There’s freedom of speech and then there’s arson and committing felonies. The riots of 2020 were an unfortunate circumstance that went far beyond expressing their freedom of speech or ‘blowing off steam’ as one leftist politician put it.
    One does not have the right to walk down State Street burning buildings as a sign of free speech.

    1. Priscilla Cushman Avatar
      Priscilla Cushman

      hmmm… When you talked about the riots of 2020, I immediately thought you meant the Jan 6 insurrection… Then I realized you were probably talking about what happened after Georg Floyd was murdered. Hopefully BOTH riots are worthy of condemnation, not just one. Then it occurred to me that this is where people fall apart: is only ONE riot worthy of condemnation? The one you feel less sympathetic to? Or can we say together that all arson and violence is condemned? I suppose if you were in DC on Jan 6 and then left, you would want to distinguish between a rally and then what happened next. I lived in downtown Minneapolis during the week(s) that Floyd was murdered. The protests were peaceful until “umbrella man” (white guy with ulterior motives) torched the auto parts store. The next couple days, lots of out of state cars were parked in my neighborhood and when we walked down by the river there were RVs with confederate flags. The gas station near me was set on fire by a set of white folks from those encampments. They were leaving gasoline cans in our hedges and we were hosing down our fences every night in case of fires. Once there is a riot, opportunists use the chaos to loot. That is not a political statement, it is just criminal behavior. Yet it was the peaceful protest by Black Lives Matter that was blamed, and then, by proxy, “the left”. We need to be far more informed about the distinction between Protest, which is our freedom of speech right, and Violence which needs to be fairly condemned by both sides without it leaking into a political commentary and blame.

  9. Nancy O'Donnell Avatar
    Nancy O’Donnell

    I can truly empathize with you.. I’m on the other end but have really tried to be open, ask, understand. I have 2 close friends w the rule no politic talk because I value their friendship.
    I am trying to accept the election….it’s not conservative vs liberal . I HATE. some of the ways MY money is spent.. It’s what kind of a role model I want kids to have.. I disliked blow jobs behind Clinton’s desk. Lies, hatred, bullying. rape , prejudice…I don’t give a shit about parties just human decency.

  10. Donna Kuhl Avatar

    This article and many responses exemplify cognitive dissonance. Republican ideology,if that’s your conservatism,is rigid and regressive,taking control of others beliefs and values. Maybe it’s time to reexamine the consequences of their policies before you wonder why people disparage you.

  11. I have experienced the same type of lack of human understanding from both the left and the right. I am an independent who has voted for libertarian candidates whenever there has been one with a message that has the potential to bring together the opposite hardcore democrats and hardcore republicans. I have been equally offended by both the right and the left.
    Both sides are equally guilty in perpetuating this dissonance. Believe me. We are in trouble in this world. We need to STOP immediately with this rhetoric. We need to listen. We need to understand. We need to work together, not only here in this country. We have to somehow convey this message throughout the entire world. The world is getting smaller by the minute. The universe(s) is/are getting smaller by the minute. Our existence on this planet and within this universe is getting shorter by the minute. My only hope is for just one minute, we all come together, all of us on this little spec in space, and say “Yes let’s all help everyone to help each other”.

  12. Kendra Larkin Avatar
    Kendra Larkin

    Thank you, thank you, thank you, Richard.

  13. Ray Clements Avatar
    Ray Clements

    The problem is not conservatism. The problem is Trumpism. Political views are open to discussion; morality, ethics, and honesty are not. Donald Trump is a bad person; he’s always been a bad person, and he will always be a bad person. The fact that Republicans have declared him their savior, says much more about the current conservative perspective than they want to admit.

  14. Priscilla Cushman Avatar
    Priscilla Cushman

    I am a Republican and I often disagree with my liberal neighbors. I would be happy to have a lawn sign that expresses my views. Trouble is, Trump and his MAGA cult are not conservative. Instead you have a set of people for whom facts are irrelevant – from controlling the weather, to Jewish space lasers, to vaccine disinformation, to saying the previous election was stolen – you can go on and on. What can anyone do in the face of such absurdity? Juries and courts are disregarded, science is dismissed as bias, health experts are ignored – you cannot fight fixed opinions that ignore facts or logic, and which are supported by a Murdoch empire that uses sensationalism to rake in billions. It is no longer about policies, with which reasonable people can disagree. We need some REAL conservatives with the spine to stand up to a vengeful narcissist and reclaim the conservative viewpoint.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *